top of page


A Deep Dive into NHL Goaltender Contracts: Unveiling the Top Value Deals in the Crease

The sanctum of the crease boasts a pantheon of shot-stoppers whose brilliance can elevate a team to transcendent heights.

In the dynamic realm of ice hockey, goaltending stands as a pinnacle position. Revered as the linchpin that can turn the tides of games, goaltenders bear the brunt of responsibility for a team's fortunes. With a keen eye on the hockey landscape, it's evident that the goalie's role, while crucial, is also one of the most enigmatic aspects of the sport. The elusive nature of their performance often makes predictions based on historical metrics a convoluted task. Conventional goaltender statistics, clouded by the influence of surrounding team dynamics, compound the complexity of assessing individual player contributions. Yet, in the midst of this volatility, a handful of prudent general managers have masterfully navigated the goaltending landscape, securing deals that encapsulate both potential and value.

The sanctum of the crease boasts a pantheon of shot-stoppers whose brilliance can elevate a team to transcendent heights. However, despite their paramount significance, signing goaltenders to long-term contracts remains a double-edged sword. The inherent uncertainty coupled with the fear of substantial underperformance has deterred some executives from splurging on the position. 

Instead, they opt to construct a sturdy lineup around a more affordable goaltending option. Admittedly, the journey is fraught with risk, but the vast expanse of the hockey universe holds several astute deals waiting to be discovered.

Embarking on an expedition to identify these deals requires a meticulous dissection of player contracts, gauging the likelihood of surpassing their cap hit throughout the tenure. Naturally, the longevity of the deal plays a pivotal role, albeit with a caveat; deals with a single year remaining and dazzling overachievement may offer a transitory discount. So, who are these paragons of value in the net?

1. Jake Oettinger: Steadfast Rise in Dallas

A keen observer might have pinpointed the Dallas Stars' foresight when they penned a deal for Jake Oettinger last September. The course of the past 11 months has only reaffirmed the wisdom of this move. Oettinger's steady ascent across three NHL seasons showcases his relentless commitment to excellence. His maturation is evident in the increasing workload he shouldered, culminating in a workhorse performance last season. A mere facet of the budget at $4 million annually, Oettinger's cap hit currently ranks 23rd amongst NHL goaltenders. Yet, as the market evolves, this contract's value will undoubtedly soar.

Possessing the complete repertoire, Oettinger encapsulates the essence of a Vezina Trophy contender for years to come. The synergy of size, athleticism, and an innate reading of the game places him firmly in the championship conversation. More promisingly for the Stars, this deal grants them the luxury of Oettinger's restricted free-agent status when the contract reaches its culmination in the summer of 2025.

2. Juuse Saros: Defying Odds in Nashville

The enigma of future goaltender performance often hinges on the encompassing team's dynamics. Juuse Saros shattered this stereotype during a season of transcendent brilliance. Despite donning the Nashville Predators jersey amidst a deluge of challenges, Saros emerged as an unrivaled performer. Forsaking the influence of a lackluster defense, he brandished a staggering arsenal of statistics, leading the league in goals saved above expected and wins above replacement. Enveloped in a $5 million cap hit for two more seasons, Saros embodies the promise of continued transcendence.

The bedrock of Saros's success lies in his precise edgework and elite athleticism, proving that goaltenders standing shy of 6 feet can conquer the NHL landscape. A fixture in the upper echelons of Vezina voting, this Finnish prodigy displays no sign of stagnation at the age of 28.

3. Linus Ullmark: A Season of Triumph in Boston

Joined by the likes of Saros, Linus Ullmark clinches the top echelon of goaltender value. A twin deal in both duration and finances, Ullmark's tenure in Boston exhibits an astonishing ability to outshine his cap hit. The disparity between him and Saros rests on experience and context. While Ullmark's trophy cabinet gleams, the latter's track record stands as a testament to his enduring prowess. Yet, with Boston undergoing a transition, Ullmark is primed for a more demanding role. His track record of resilience during trying times ensures this contract remains an epitome of value.

4. Filip Gustavsson: A Rising Star in Minnesota

The dawn of the 2022-23 season heralded the meteoric rise of Filip Gustavsson. A crescendo in performance positioned him as an equal to the likes of Andrei Vasilevskiy in GSAx and save percentage. Equally impressive were his in-game control and mastery of angles, painting the portrait of an unflinching goalie. Signing an extension with the Minnesota Wild, Gustavsson's potential to sustain such excellence reverberates with promise. A $3.75 million cap hit for three years might just be one of the league's best-kept secrets.

5. Stuart Skinner: Edmonton's Thrifty Investment

Amidst the constellation of goaltender gems, Stuart Skinner emanates a luminous glow of potential. A savior for the Edmonton Oilers in a previous season, Skinner's rapid contract extension unveiled managerial prescience. The rookie's emergence carried him to an All-Star Game appearance and the precipice of the Calder Trophy. Embarking on a new chapter, Skinner's cap hit of $2.6 million over three years etches him as a value diamond in the rough.

Honorable Mentions: The Gems Yet Unearthed

Nestled among the elite, Logan Thompson and Joseph Woll beckon attention. By the numbers, their cap hits appear below league minimums, owing to their initial contract terms. Emerging as exemplars of netminding excellence, their prospects shine. Thompson's commanding presence led the Golden Knights while Woll exhibited dexterity for the Maple Leafs. With minuscule cap hits, they underscore the notion that value is often found in the uncharted.

In a hockey cosmos fraught with uncertainty, these goaltender contracts emerge as guiding stars. A synergy of potential and contract prudence sets the stage for future triumphs, navigating the intricate dance of salary cap management while securing the beacon of a stalwart goaltender.

Austyn McFadden


Thursday, August 10, 2023

  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram

Empowering the next generation

of sports storytellers

© 2023 by First in Flight Creative

bottom of page